여헌 장현광 성리설 연구의 쟁점과 과제Issues in the history of study on Jang Hyeonkwng's Theory of Li and Ch'i
- Other Titles
- Issues in the history of study on Jang Hyeonkwng's Theory of Li and Ch'i
- Authors
- 김용헌
- Issue Date
- Mar-2010
- Publisher
- (사)한국인물사연구회
- Keywords
- Jang Hyeongwang; Tao-monism; Li-monism; li-gi-gyeong-wi-seo; lli-gi-il-won(原)-non; li-gi-il-bon(本)-non; 장현광; 리기경위설; 도일원론; 리일원론; 리기일원(原)론; 리기일본론
- Citation
- 한국인물사연구, no.13, pp.75 - 110
- Indexed
- KCI
- Journal Title
- 한국인물사연구
- Number
- 13
- Start Page
- 75
- End Page
- 110
- URI
- https://scholarworks.bwise.kr/hanyang/handle/2021.sw.hanyang/175246
- ISSN
- 1738-3307
- Abstract
- Jang Hyeongwang is one of the prominent confucian scholars in Chosun Dynasty. Jang Hyeongwang belonged to the Toegye School. Nevertheless his theory of Li and Ch`i(gi), what is called li-gi-gyeong-wi-seol in some respect, was not similar to Toegye's but to Yulgok´s. So, after 1920s, the philosophy of Jang has been studied by many modern Confucianism researchers.
Roughly speaking, many researchers' arguments have been focused on two main issues. On the question of where Jang`s theory stands between Toegye`s and Yulgok´s, there are four different views. While some of modern scholars hold a view that Jang´s theory is closer to Yulgok`s, others maintain that Jang succeeded Toegye's philosophical mind whose main intention was to enhance the position of Li. In the other hand, Some scholars have an opinion that Jang`s theory is a proper compromise between Toegye's and Yulgok`s, others insist that Jang`s theory is original theory transcending both Toegye's and Yulgok`s.
Another issue is concerning how Jang`s theory of Li and Ch´i can be ontologically conceptualized. Over this topic Tao-monism has been in conflict with Li-monism. Some people who regard Jang`s theory as Tao-monism understand that Tao is the only substance in Jang`s philosophy. Others who regard Jang`s theory as Li-monism insist that Li is the only substance in Jang`s philosophy. Besides, there are opinions that Jang`s theory can be prescribed as li-gi-il-won(原)-non or li-gi-il-bon(本)-non looking upon Li and Ch´i as one origin. Hence, according to them, the main characteristics of Jang's theory is the unified relations between Li and Ch'i in this world.
- Files in This Item
-
Go to Link
- Appears in
Collections - 서울 인문과학대학 > 서울 철학과 > 1. Journal Articles
![qrcode](https://api.qrserver.com/v1/create-qr-code/?size=55x55&data=https://scholarworks.bwise.kr/hanyang/handle/2021.sw.hanyang/175246)
Items in ScholarWorks are protected by copyright, with all rights reserved, unless otherwise indicated.